Writing Checklist

Reduce clutter and increase clarity of any document with these rules.

Stanford MOOC on Writing in the Sciences

This writing checklist is mostly from advice in this massively open online course. You can take it yourself for free at your own pace.

Reviewing Writing

Use these lists to check off your progress in writing and reviewing.

- [ ] Run a spell checker.
- [ ] Get rid of unnecessary prepositional phrases -- author clearing throat (e.g., "It can be shown that...").
- [ ] Get rid of extraneous adverbs (very, really, quite, basically, generally).
- [ ] Get rid of there are/there is.
- [ ] Get rid of extraneous prepositions ("the meeting happened on Monday" -> "the meeting happened Monday") ("they agreed that it was true" -> "they agreed it was true").
- [ ] Get rid of passive voice (is/was/are/were/be/been/am + past tense verb), replace with active voice.
- [ ] Cite all images, methods, software, and empirical data. Review [the principles](https://www.force11.org/software-citation-principles) and try [CiteAs](https://citeas.org/about) if necessary.

Enhancing Clarity

As Shakespeare wrote in Hamlet, “Brevity is the soul of wit.”

- [ ] Be concise and direct.
- [ ] Using "very" suggests that a better word exists; replace it where possible.
- [ ] Make sure that articles such as "a," "the," "some," "any," and "each" appear where necessary.
- [ ] Ensure all subjects must match the plurality of their verbs (saying "Apples is tasty" is wrong, but "Apples are tasty" is correct).
- [ ] Recover verbs that were turned into nouns ("obtain estimates of" -> "estimates"; "provides a description of" -> "describes").
- [ ] Use the form <noun> <verb>ion over <verb>ion of <noun> (for example, convert "calculation of velocity" to "velocity calculation").
- [ ] Reduce vague words like "important" or "methodologic."
- [ ] Reduce acronyms/jargon.
- [ ] Expand all acronyms on first use (rely on the acros.tex file and glossaries package to automate this).
- [ ] Turn negatives to positives (she was not often right -> she was usually wrong).
- [ ] Do not bury the verb (keep the predicate close to the subject at the beginning of the sentence).
- [ ] Refer to software consistently by name.
- [ ] Italicize unusual or unfamiliar words or phrases when you use them.
- [ ] If you use an uncommon word, consider changing it or defining it in its first usage.
- [ ] Only use the word "significant" when referring to statistical significance.

Enhancing Style

You are a human writing for other humans: Make the wording exciting, and remember your audience includes readers who might not know as much jargon as you.

- [ ] Vary your sentence structure to keep readers engaged.
- [ ] Do not use contractions in technical writing.
- [ ] Use punctuation to help you to vary your sentence structure.
- [ ] Follow the convention that the power to separate is (in order of increasing power): comma, colon, em dash, parentheses, semicolon, and period.
- [ ] In increasing order of formality: dash, parentheses, all others. Do not overdo the em dash and parentheses.
- [ ] Check that if there's a list in a sentence, it shouldn't come before the colon.
- [ ] Always use isotopic notation like `$^{239}Pu$`. Never `$Pu-239$` or `$plutonium-239$`.
- [ ] Strengthen your verbs (use sparingly: is, are, was, were, be, been, am).
- [ ] Only use "large" when referring to size.
- [ ] Do not use the word "when" unless referring to a time (try "if" instead).
- [ ] Clarify or change misused/overused words where necessary (e.g., code, input, output, different, value, amount, model).
- [ ] Each sentence/paragraph should logically follow the previous sentence/paragraph.
- [ ] Examples should use variables instead of numbers and symbolic math instead of acronyms.

Enhancing Grammar

- [ ] "Data" is plural (e.g., "the data are critical").
- [ ] Compare to (point out similarities between different things) vs. compared with (point out differences between similar things)
- [ ] Elemental symbols (Ni, Li, Na, Pu) are capitalized, but their names are not (nickel, lithium, sodium, plutonium).
- [ ] Do not use the word "where" unless referring to a location (try "such that," or "in which").
- [ ] Avoid run-on sentences.
- [ ] The preposition "of" shows belonging, relations, or references. The preposition "for" shows purpose, destination, amount, or recipients. They are not interchangeable.

Enhancing Punctuation

- [ ] Commas and periods go inside end quotes, except when there is a parenthetical reference afterward.
- [ ] Colons and semicolons go outside closed quotations.
- [ ] A semicolon connects two independent clauses OR separates items when the list contains internal punctuation.
- [ ] Use a colon to introduce a list, quote, explanation, conclusion, or amplification.
- [ ] The Oxford comma must appear in lists (e.g., "lions, tigers, and bears").
- [ ] Use hyphens to join words acting as a single adjective before a noun (e.g., "well-known prankster"), not after a noun (e.g., "the prankster is well known").
- [ ] Two words joined by a hyphen in title case should both be capitalized.
- [ ] Hyphens join a prefix to a capitalized word, figure, or letter (e.g., pre-COVID, T-cell receptor, post-1800s); compound numbers (e.g., sixty-six); words to the prefixes ex, self, and all (e.g., ex-sitter, self-made, all-knowing); and words to the suffix elect (e.g., president-elect).

Using Latin

- [ ] The Latin abbreviations viz., i.e., and e.g. should all have commas before and after them (e.g., "We can classify a large star as a red giant, e.g., Stephenson 2-18").
- [ ] The Latin abbreviations cf., et al., or q.v. should not automatically have commas after them.
- [ ] The abbreviation of *versus* (vs.) should always have a period in American English and is used to contrast things.
- [ ] You should never say "and etc.", because "et" means and in Latin.
- [ ] Abbreviations including "et" should not have a period after "et" because it is a whole word.
- [ ] Some abbreviations need capitalization (e.g., "N.B.," which means "note well").
- [ ] Latin (or any non-English) words other than et are usually italicized (e.g., *in situ*, *in vivo*, *in vitro,* and *ab initio*).

Tables and Figures

- [ ] The text should refer to all tables and figures.
- [ ] When referring to figures by their number, use `Figure 1` and `Table 1.` They should be capitalized and not abbreviated (not `fig. 1` or `figure 1`).
- [ ] Align all columns of numbers in tables such that the decimals line up.
- [ ] All values should probably have the same number of significant digits in a single column.
- [ ] Give units for each numerical column.
- [ ] A table should have only three horizontal lines (no vertical lines and no more than three).

Enhancing Math

- [ ] Define all variables with units. If unitless, indicate this is the case `$[-]$`.
- [ ] Subscripts should be brief and can be avoided with common notation. For example, `$\dot{m}$` is better than `$m_f$` which is superior to `$m_{flow}$`.
- [ ] Variable names should be symbols rather than words `m` is better than `mass` and `\ksi` is better than `one_time_use_variable`.
- [ ] The notation `$3.0\times10^{12}$` is preferred over `$3e12$`.
- [ ] Equations should be part of a sentence.
- [ ] Equations should be in the `align` environment. Align them at the `=` sign.
- [ ] Variables should be defined in the `align` environment, not buried in paragraphs.

Here’s an example of an equation:

A line has the form
\begin{align}
y&=mx + b
\intertext{where}
y&= \mbox{ height of the line, also known as rise [m]}\nonumber\\
m&= \mbox{ slope [-]}\nonumber\\
x&=\mbox{ independent parameter, known as run [m]}\nonumber\\
b&= \mbox{ y intercept [m].}
\end{align}